video
play-sharp-fill

The Argument

  • FACT, the new deadline: The company that proposed a gravel mine in Norvell Township plans to submit updated materials and move forward with its application by Nov. 23, according to an email received by the township supervisor. During Norvell Township’s Monday, Nov. 16 meeting, Supervisor Andrew Haystead said attorney Stephen Estey emailed him to say American Aggregates of Michigan is finalizing updated materials and anticipates scheduling a public hearing after Nov. 23. (FACT: MLive, Nov. 2026.)
  • FACT, the proposal: American Aggregates of Michigan, a subsidiary of the Edward C. Levy Co. of Dearborn, proposes to mine gravel and sand from two sites on 626.4 acres on either side of Horning Road, west and south of Watkins Lake, using bucket loaders, transport trucks and conveyors, with an aggregate processing plant in the northern portion of the project area. The mining would occur within 300 feet of the border of Watkins Lake State Park and County Preserve. (FACT: Detroit Free Press, Nov. 18, 2026.)
  • FACT, the DNR warning: Michigan DNR Director M. Scott Bowen, in a Nov. 5 letter to Supervisor Haystead, wrote in the DNR’s capacity as steward of the state park and a significant adjacent property owner: “We are deeply concerned that the proposed mine would impair the natural resources of the park through changing and diminishing the pattern of ground and surface water flow and the water quality of that flow.” Bowen also cited harm to birds and wildlife and diminished park use from trucking, dust, noise and visual impacts. (FACT: Detroit Free Press, Nov. 18, 2026; DNR letter, Nov. 5, 2026.)
  • FACT, the scale in the application: According to the DNR’s reading of the application, the mine would haul gravel at an average rate of nine trucks an hour, 10 to 12 hours a day, Monday through Friday and Saturday mornings, for 20 years. Watkins Lake and its surrounding park land are officially designated a Waterfowl Refuge, providing habitat for migrating and breeding ducks, geese, grebes and related waterfowl. (FACT: Detroit Free Press, Nov. 18, 2026.)
  • FACT, the company’s answer: Edward C. Levy Co. operations manager Reuben Maxbauer said in an emailed statement: “We are confident that our decades of experience demonstrate our ability to responsibly mine while protecting sensitive natural features,” adding that sand and gravel are key ingredients for concrete and asphalt, and that mines closer to markets lower transportation costs and fuel use. (FACT: Detroit Free Press, Nov. 18, 2026.)
  • FACT, the opposition: A Facebook group, Irish Hills Concerned Citizens Group, has more than 2,000 followers, and yard signs opposing the mine dot lawns throughout the area. The group’s president, Sybil Kolon, argues the true truck rate is 18 trucks per hour counting trucks coming and going, and says of the township: “We think Norvell Township is within its rights to reject this. We think it’s time for them to call the question.” (FACT: Detroit Free Press, Nov. 18, 2026.)
Watkins Lake at sunset with waterfowl

Why Nov. 23 matters

(COMMENTARY: This fight has run for the better part of a year. The permit application was filed on Nov. 17, 2025, and township officials have spent months seeking additional information from the applicant. The Nov. 23 resubmittal is the moment the application becomes current again, with a public hearing anticipated after that date. Until the updated materials are filed, every argument on both sides is being made about a plan the company itself is still revising.)

(COMMENTARY: The DNR letter changes the weight of the room. A state agency that manages the park next door has now told the township, in writing, that the mine would compromise the park’s general management plan by impacting its waters, wetlands, wildlife and park users. That does not decide the permit. Norvell Township decides the permit. But it means the township board will be voting with the park’s own steward on the record against the project as proposed, and that record will matter whichever way the vote goes.)

What is still unknown

  • FACT: Norvell Township’s timeline for approving or rejecting the mine is uncertain. (FACT: Detroit Free Press, Nov. 18, 2026.)
  • FACT: No public hearing date has been announced in the sources checked. The company anticipates scheduling one after Nov. 23. (FACT: MLive, Nov. 2026.)
  • This page will not guess at the contents of the updated materials before they are filed, or at how any individual trustee will vote.

Sources

Gravel dump trucks on a dusty rural road near Watkins Lake

FAQs

When will the updated mine application be filed?

American Aggregates of Michigan is finalizing updated materials and plans to move forward by Nov. 23, per an email from attorney Stephen Estey reported by Supervisor Andrew Haystead at the Nov. 16 township meeting (MLive).

How big is the proposed mine?

Two sites totaling 626.4 acres on either side of Horning Road, within 300 feet of Watkins Lake State Park and County Preserve, per the Detroit Free Press.

What did the DNR actually say?

In a Nov. 5 letter, DNR Director M. Scott Bowen said the agency is deeply concerned the mine would impair the park’s water flow and water quality, harm birds and wildlife, and diminish park use through trucking, dust, noise and visual impacts.

Who decides whether the mine is approved?

Norvell Township, which has been considering the permit application, first filed Nov. 17, 2025, for the better part of a year. A public hearing is anticipated after Nov. 23.


AI-generated header image: the header image for this article is an AI-generated illustration, not a photograph.

Want Jackson’s top local stories in one place? Browse the businesses shaping the area in the NeighborClick Local directory — JOIN the FREE Private Insider List for local stories, business spotlights, community updates and even if you don’t have business you’ll be an Insider.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.